Skip to main content

Correcting the record on the heritage of Western Civ (letter)

Matt Reed’s response to my essay on the humanities and general education nicely applies the issue to community colleges.  Before doing that, however, he issues some criticisms that must be answered. 

First, he states that he will “leave it to those in Stanford’s orbit” to assess my description of what happened after the school scrapped Western Civ. He repeats the point a paragraph later. This is strange. The links are there for Dr. Reed to check sources, but he prefers to insinuate a suspicion of my truthfulness. The name for that is passive aggression. 

Next, he raises the advent of AP and IB as causes of English’s decline, not the reason I gave (that profs lost the conviction and erudition needed to present momentous, sweeping visions of civilization to the young). The problem here is that when humanities enrollments plunged right after Stanford made the change in 1969, IB and AP were barely around. One point of my essay was to go back in time before the 80’s Canon Wars in order to show the pattern at work before conservative critics came along to decry the "politicization of the humanities." Note that the restoration of Western Civ at Stanford in 1980 was led by a prominent feminist historian, not a Bill Bennett-type. 

Next, Dr. Reed questions my choice of 1970-71 as a benchmark for enrollments in English, stating that year’s rate of 7+ percent of all bachelor’s degrees conferred going to English majors “was the exception, not the rule.”

I have heard this point before, and it’s wrong. Ten years before, the share of all degrees that English claimed was 6.5%. One year later, the rate rose to 7%. (https://nces.ed.gov/pubs93/93442.pdf -- See Table 29, which used the label “Letters”)  He calls 1970 “a peak,” but a quick look at the data shows it was no anomaly.

Finally, one has to wonder whether Dr. Reed really understands the fullness of the Western Civ heritage that so many schools once boldly prescribed to every incoming student. It is downright inspiring to read catalog descriptions of such a course back then, which flow with surety and promise. I enjoyed every moment I spent in Stanford's archives a few years back.

Dr. Reed, however, calls it a “greatest hits collection.” That's a trivializing metaphor that misses the august import of the whole, the genius/masterpiece factor, the historic stature of the things freshmen will absorb.  It ennobled them, and Stanford students said so (excepting the activist kids, who were a small portion of the student body). The reaction is the same today. The reason the humanities core remains in place at Columbia is that alums remember it ardently and preserve its reputation. 

Every youth deserves this inheritance, to know that there is something much better than youth culture drivel and Web chatter, that he lives in the shadow of brilliance and beauty and epic conduct. That goes for the low-income, first-generation community college kid as well as the Ivy Leaguer.  

--Mark Bauerlein
Professor emeritus of English
Emory University

Editorial Tags: 
Is this diversity newsletter?: 
Disable left side advertisement?: 
Is this Career Advice newsletter?: 
Live Updates: 
liveupdates0
Most Popular: 
3
In-Article Advertisement High: 
6
In-Article related stories: 
9
In-Article Advertisement Low: 
12


Udimi - Buy Solo Ads from Inside Higher Ed https://ift.tt/Xhkyqns
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tips and Strategies for Remote Learning (March 2020)

For the past four weeks, starting two weeks before our Spring Break last week, teachers, administrators and staff at our school have been preparing for “remote school” for students as a result of the coronavirus / COVID-19 crisis. On March 19, 2020, our Head of School sent out a letter to our parents including information about our remote learning plans and FAQs for parents . If your school is currently preparing for remote learning ( as all Oklahoma public school districts now appear to be , pending tomorrow’s state school board meeting vote) I encourage you to review these publicly shared documents and information. As our school’s “Technology Integration and Innovation Specialist” this year, I’ve been building an instructional site for our teachers to support remote learning, on support.casady.org , which is openly licensed CC-BY . This collaborative effort with many other teachers and members of our school staff has provided a good opportunity to curate as well as present instruc...

5 Tips for Embracing Outdoor Learning in Any Setting

In a year when all schools look different from usual, some teachers are embracing the outdoors as their classroom. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention included outdoor learning in recommended strategies for schools to reduce the spread of COVID-19, and research has shown positive instructional outcomes from such methods. Long-time outdoor educators also tout the social and emotional benefits . But getting started can feel daunting. Below are five tips from experienced teachers for trying outdoor learning in any setting. Look for possibilities in different spaces Becky Schnekser is teaching K-5 science fully outdoors this year at a private school in Virginia Beach. She has the advantage of a well developed outdoor classroom, but that’s not a prerequisite. “Any outdoor space is an opportunity, whether you have a beautiful wooded area or you have concrete jungle,” she said. From sidewalk math to history walks to socially distanced singing , educators are finding wa...

Guidance on Accreditation for Governing Boards

With accreditation under intensified scrutiny from state legislators and other quarters, two national associations have issued a joint statement reminding governing boards of the importance of higher education’s quality assurance system and the role they should play in it. The Joint Advisory Statement on Accreditation & Governing Boards 2022 , from the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges and the Council for Higher Education Accreditation, refreshes a 2009 statement the two groups issued at another time when accreditation had taken heat, then from the Bush administration’s Spellings Commission on the Future of Higher Education. More recently, legislators in Florida have proposed legislation that would require colleges to regularly change accreditors and give them the right to sue accreditors that take regulatory action against them. The Florida measure came in response to an accrediting agency’s inquiry into external influences over governance at two ...