Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts from January, 2023

Stopping the DeSantis Wrecking Ball

Blog:  Just Visiting Ron DeSantis wants people to believe that the nation’s public universities have gotten away from their core mission of education and become bastions of wokeness run amok, but in Florida, “where woke goes to die” he’s just not going to let that happen. Now, those of us who are more familiar with what actually happens at colleges and universities know that this is not at all true, and that DeSantis is peddling transparent B.S. as part of a broader push to consolidate his power over public institutions in his state, not just higher ed, but K-12 education as well. So far, the courts have found some problems with DeSantis’s initiatives, but he doesn’t seem to care. In K-12 education, with the Stop Woke Act, he’s created a sufficient atmosphere of intimidation to have teachers  covering up their classroom libraries lest they risk a felony charge. Such actions would surely be unconstitutional, but this simply becomes another political talking point, the establ

How to Improve Teaching Quality and Effectiveness

Blog:  Higher Ed Gamma Whatever else academic freedom means, at many colleges and universities, it is the right to teach however one wants without regard to learning outcomes.  Indeed, at the more selective, better resourced institutions, academic freedom and tenure also imply the right to teach whatever one wants, when one wants. Pedagogy, assignments and activities, and assessment methods, all are up to the instructor. I hate to say this, but I think the following generalizations are largely true.  All too many college instructors:  Like to occupy the class’ center stage, whether lecturing or leading discussions. Only to a limited extend do they distribute responsibility to their students.   Teach pretty much like they were taught. Too many have no particular knowledge of or interest in the science of learning.   Define active learning very narrowly.  Too many equate active learning with discussion and debate as opposed to inquiry or problem solving or activities

DeSantis Proposes Limits on Higher Ed ‘Indoctrination’

Florida governor Ron DeSantis, a Republican, said Tuesday that he would ban diversity, equity and inclusion programs in the state’s university system. He also said that he would require “civics institutes” at the University of Florida, Florida International University and Florida State University. The institutes would develop courses and curricula “that can be used to educate the next generation on the values of liberty and constitutionalism.” And he said he would change faculty hiring in a way that presidents would be “reestablishing their authority over the hiring process.” The Tampa Bay Times reported that DeSantis’s aides distributed a copy of a flier that said the changes and others would promote “education not indoctrination.” He also proposed changes in standards and course content “to ensure higher education is rooted in the values of liberty and Western tradition.” His plan would require colleges to “prioritize graduating students with degrees that lead to high-wage jo

Teaching AI writing in terms of co-authorship (opinion)

The next-level artificial intelligence capabilities of ChatGPT, a chat bot released in late November by the research company OpenAI, have inspired many predictions, both drastic and ecstatic, for the end of essay writing, if not education as we know it. While some in higher education view ChatGPT as a learning tool to be leveraged and others consider it a threat to be addressed exclusively through prohibition and plagiarism detection, nearly all agree that the technology’s ability to simulate human thinking and writing is remarkable, if not uncanny, and therefore worthy of our immediate attention. Whether we like it or not, HAL 9000 has transferred to our campus this spring semester. The real question now is definitional: On what terms should educators interact with writing generated from machines? Though it has not received much notice, OpenAI proposes an answer that is usefully old-fashioned and worth pondering in our ongoing deliberations: we should interact as authors. In the

The SAT and ACT Are Less Important Than You Might Think

Blog:  Higher Ed Policy More than 80% of U.S. colleges and universities do not require applicants to take standardized tests – like the SAT or the ACT . That proportion of institutions with test-optional policies has more than doubled since the spring of 2020 . And for the fall of 2023, some 85 institutions won’t even consider standardized test scores when reviewing applications. That includes the entire University of California system. Currently, only 4% of colleges that use the Common Application system require a standardized test such as the SAT or the ACT for admission. Even before the pandemic, more than 1,000 colleges and universities had either test-optional or so-called “test-blind” policies. But as the pandemic unfolded, more than 600 additional institutions followed suit. At the time, many college officials noted that health concerns and other logistics associated with test-taking made them want to reduce student stress and risk. Concerns about racial equit

Student loan ombudsman: Failures in system fuel disparities

Image:  The federal student aid system needs “robust interventions” in order to break the cycle of inequity in higher education finance, the ombudsman for the agency that runs the system concluded in its annual report. “At each stage of the student aid lifecycle, the higher education finance model disproportionately fails families of color,” the ombudsman’s report says. “Collectively, these failures perpetuate disparities in student and borrower outcomes and may ultimately widen the racial wealth gap. If policymakers wish to restore the promise of higher education and the pathway to the middle class for all, they should examine the student loan safety net through an equity lens and consider expanding existing programs to ensure more equitable outcomes for student loan borrowers.” The ombudsman’s annual report is a change in tone from previous iterations, experts said, but one that reflects the administration’s recent focus on shoring up the student loan safety net by overha

Can the English Major Be Saved?

Blog:  Higher Ed Gamma Perhaps as an undergraduate you read Oscar Wilde’s mirthful, satiric essay “The Critic as Artist.”  Subtitled “Upon the Importance of Doing Nothing and Discussing Everything,” it contains some of Wilde’s most memorable quips and witticisms:   An idea that is not dangerous is unworthy of being called an idea at all. When people agree with me, I always feel that I must be wrong. There is no sin except stupidity. Yes: the public is wonderfully tolerant. It forgives everything except genius. Ironically, it’s the essay’s major source of satire – the primacy of criticism over the art that it interprets and evaluates – that has, to a surprising extent, been realized.  For nearly a century, academic critics of literature – from I.A. Richards and Cleanth Brooks, and Lionel Trilling to Derrida, de Man, Foucault, and Lyotard, to Judith Butler, Stanley Fish, and Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak today – have been regarded, in large parts of the discipline, as more i

Addressing Failures of Implementation

Blog:  Beyond Transfer In 2021 and 2022, AACRAO staff (American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers) joined the growing national conversation on re-envisioning transfer, sharing research and recommendations in addition to highlighting the infrastructure deficiencies and need for a more global perspective in the “Beyond Transfer” blog. AACRAO's participation in these discussions spans decades and includes providing guidance on transfer student practice and policy for domestic and international students. As a leader in the academic and enrollment services space, our research highlights transfer policy gaps and spotlights successful practices that drive both institutional and learner success. In 2023, we want to highlight the role and work our members do to move the needle on improving transfer and credit mobility to spur student success. As institutions struggle to adapt in the wake of the Covid pandemic and advocate for the value of higher educa