Skip to main content

A Task Less Measured

 

I’ll admit having spent most of the last several days glued to the news and social media, following the events in Ukraine.  It has been heartening to see the Western countries coordinate their sanctions as well as they have, and to see the Ukrainians defend themselves so well.  It has been disheartening to see how shallow much of the American media coverage has been.  

 

That’s where my educator side kicks in.  Our students need to know enough to make sense of events like these.

 

Putin’s decision to invade had a history.  For example, President Trump’s first impeachment was over trying to blackmail Ukrainian President Zelensky by withholding military aid unless Zelensky offered dirt on Joe Biden.  (Characteristically, Zelensky refused.)  When those dots aren’t connected, we get a misleading picture.

 

Or we could zoom out more, and look at both the Cold War and the history of Europe in the 20th century.  The old joke is that Europe produced more history than it could consume, so it had to export it.  Wars over territory are hardly new to Europe.  The “end of history” that some were happy to declare around 1991 was an illusion in ways both obvious and subtle.  One of the more damaging aspects of the “end of history” thesis is that it licensed people to take their eye off the ball.  We’re feeling the effects of that now.

 

Those of us old enough to remember communism may crack a smile at seeing one of the ways the Western countries are sanctioning Russian oligarchs is freezing or seizing their property.  

 

My concern as an educator, especially at the community college level, is that the valid task of job preparation has largely eclipsed the task of educating citizens for a democracy.  

 

I can understand how that happened.  Solid middle-class jobs have become less certain over the last few decades, and the “end of history” folks assured us that the question of democracy had been settled.  It seemed prudent to shift focus towards the immediate.  And there’s an obvious sense in which people need first to take care of their basic needs before they can devote meaningful attention to things happening thousands of miles away.

 

But to the extent that we reduce education to training, we neglect the crucial task of preparing citizens to run the country.  

 

In fact, there’s a move afoot now to stifle any discussion of “divisive” topics at all.  By stigmatizing the simple fact of disagreement, these proposals aim to strike at the heart of democracy.  Given freedom to speak, people will disagree; James Madison noted that in the Federalist Papers, and it’s still true.  The only way to prevent disagreement – or deliberation, if you prefer – is to deny the freedom to speak.  That’s the point of those proposals, and anyone with a commitment to democracy needs to recognize that.

 

We routinely measure the starting salaries of graduates.  We publish graduation rates – badly measured, but still – and sometimes employment rates.  I can’t remember seeing a survey of the voting rates of a given college’s graduates.  

 

What gets measured gets funded.

 

This weekend has reminded us that democracies are fragile.  In the grand sweep of human history, they’re exceptions.  There’s no guarantee that they’ll endure.  They’re only as strong as their citizens’ devotion to them.  The citizens of Ukraine have taken to the streets to defend theirs.  We could at least bother to do some basic maintenance of our own.






 

Show on Jobs site: 
Disable left side advertisement?: 
Is this diversity newsletter?: 
Is this Career Advice newsletter?: 
Advice Newsletter publication dates: 
Sunday, February 27, 2022
Diversity Newsletter publication date: 
Sunday, February 27, 2022


Udimi - Buy Solo Ads from Inside Higher Ed https://ift.tt/L1Xetjv
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Author discusses book on grad school

Graduate school is a great mystery to students, and to some faculty members, says Jessica McCrory Calarco, the author of A Field Guide to Grad School: Uncovering the Hidden Curriculum (Princeton University Press). Calarco is an associate professor of sociology at Indiana University. She believes many faculty members (as well as graduate students, of course) will benefit from her book. She responded to questions via email. Q: How did you get the idea to write this book? Why did the issue speak to you? A: This book started as a tweet . Or, rather, as a series of tweets about the hidden curriculum of higher ed. Ph.D. student Kristen K. Smith had tweeted about the need to better educate undergrads about grad school opportunities, and it made me think about how opportunities in academe are often hidden from grad students, as well. Reflecting on my own experiences in grad school, I thought about the many times I'd found myself embarrassed because of what I didn't know -- the

Guest Blog: Where Does the Bizarre Hysteria About “Critical Race Theory” Come From?—Follow the Money!

Blog:  Just Visiting Guest Blog: Where Does the Bizarre Hysteria About “Critical Race Theory” Come From?—Follow the Money! By Isaac Kamola Trinity College Hartford, CT There are now numerous well-documented examples of wealthy right-wing and libertarian donors using that wealth to transform higher education in their own image. Between 2005 and 2019, for example, the Charles Koch Foundation has spent over  $485 million  at more than 550 universities. As demonstrated by Douglas Beets and others, many of these grants include considerable  donor influence  over what gets taught, researched, and even who gets hired. It should therefore come as no surprise that conservative megadonor, Walter Hussman Jr.,  lobbied hard  to deny the Pulitzer-prize winning journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones a tenured professorship at the UNC journalism school that bears his name. Nor that her offer of tenure, awarded through the normal channels of faculty governance, was ultimately  revoked   by a far-

Live Updates: Latest News on COVID-19 and Higher Education

Image:  Woman Charged With Faking Positive COVID-19 Test From U of Iowa   Nov. 5, 6:14 a.m. A lawyer in Colorado has been charged with faking a positive COVID-19 test from the University of Iowa to get out of a court appearance, The Gazette reported.   Emily Elizabeth Cohen was booked Tuesday on a detainer from the Boulder County Sheriff’s Office, shortly after she tweeted that the Colorado court system “just had me arrested alleging I lied about having COVID. Tweeting from cop car.”   The Boulder Daily Camera reported that Cohen is scheduled for a 10-day trial in Boulder County in Colorado starting Dec. 6 for 11 felony counts stemming from allegations she collected fees from immigrant families before losing contact with them without producing visas or work permits.   -- Scott Jaschik Judge Permits Suit Against Montana State to Go to Trial Nov. 3, 6:18 a.m. A Montana judge has ruled that a suit against Montana State University over the shift to online education